Wednesday 27 July 2011

No 10217, Wednesday 27 Jul 11, Gridman

ACROSS
1   - Being fond, yearned after a race (8) - {A}{TT}{ACHED} ATTACHED
6   - Watering-hole to circle around (4) - LOOP <-
9   - Kudos showered on the first to unlock puzzle (6) - {SUDOK*}{U} SUDOKU
10 - Thinking, I leave for primarily easy job (7) - OP(-i+e)ENING OPENING
13 - With this, one's possessed (9) - OWNERSHIP [CD]
14 - Yawn from little boy at end of term (5) - {CH}AS{M} Anno pending(Addendum - {CHAS}{M} - See comments) CHASM
15 - Then approval's back for milk source (4) - {SO}{AY<-} SOYA
16 - With such a budget you can't get designer footwear (10) - SHOESTRING [CD]
19 - Letter may come calling with this (4,6) - RENT DEMAND [CD]
21 - Pole makes ship commander drop hesitation (4) - MASTer MAST
24 - Credit to Oriental ship bringing vegetable (5) - {CR}{E}{SS} CRESS
25 - Slow journalist's mean to a learner (9) - {SUB}{NORM}{A}{L} SUBNORMAL
26 - Light in fine, rich fabric (7) - {IN}{F}{LAME} INFLAME
27 - I am inclined to accept newbie's first plan (6) - {I}{N}{TEND} INTEND
28 - Drag, without power, named useless (4) - (-p+n) NULL
29 - Binding bandage (8) - LIGATURE [DD]
DOWN
2   - Team leader doesn't begin travel to competition (7) - {T}{jOURNEY} TOURNEY
3   - Inside a panel (6) - {A}{BOARD} ABOARD
4   - Huh! No hymn put out for a novel horse race (9) -  HOUYHNHNM*
5   - Wilt as daughter comes on sorry redound (5) - {D}{ROOP<-} DROOP


7   - Nothing to frolic? I and mother return with paper folding (7) - {O}{RIG}{AM<-}{I<-} ORIGAMI
8   - Greedy persons' power on insect — that's unbelievable! (4,5,3) - {PIGS} {MIGHT] {FLY} PIGS MIGHT FLY
11 - Once the position was said to stir up (6) - {EX}{CITE} EXCITE
12 - Building up for an interpretation? (12) - CONSTRUCTION [DD]
17 - None flashed expensive jewellery — that's dignifying (9) - {ENNO*}{BLING} ENNOBLING
18 - Poems on South Arcot in the file (6) - {ODES}{SA} ODESSA
20 - Requisite fund to be distributed around the limits of Erode by end of April (7) - {N{ErodE}DFU*}{L} NEEDFUL
22 - Hospital official is a person who acts on his own, carrying money (7) - {A}{L{M}ONER} ALMONER
23 - Bird, man, worthless horse (6) - {TOM}{TIT} TOMTIT
25 - Defeat decisively in small place of turmoil (5) - {S}{HELL} SHELL



53 comments:

  1. I swayed between SHELL and SWELL, both satisfying place of turmoil, and finally settled on shell, though not 'defeat decisively', I thought.

    14 - Yawn from little boy at end of term (5) - {CH}AS{M} Anno pending CHASM

    CHAS for abbreviated Charles, I think

    ReplyDelete
  2. 14 - Yawn from little boy at end of term (5) - {CH}AS{M} Anno pending CHASM

    {CHAS(-e)}{M}

    ReplyDelete
  3. Similar to Thos for Thomas. CV, remember Thos Gregson, son of Aunt Agatha?

    ReplyDelete
  4. A solution word is repeated here from the previous crossword.

    Gridman would like to clarify that generally he ensures that no word is repeated at least in his month's bunch of six crosswords. This he does by putting the list of words in a bunch through a duplicate finder and if any is found he makes amends.

    This can be done by reworking the corner (which he has done often) or by simply swapping the crossword with another from a future bunch (which too he has done occasionally when reworking is impossible).

    However, this he didn't do this time.

    Reworking the corner in this puzzle wasn't found easy while checking it on the day prior to publication.

    ReplyDelete
  5. shell v. - come out better in a competition, race, or conflict

    See onelook dictionary

    ReplyDelete
  6. Sandhya @ 8:34,

    Have you taken 'Chase' as the name of a boy or is there another meaning to it?

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Colonel: Name of a boy - like James Hadley Chase

    ReplyDelete
  8. Readers will remember having seen in old books a single character that combines two letters together, e.g., f and i joined.

    I think it's called 'ligature'.

    Kishore, please confirm.

    In modern-day computerised setting, this character has vanished, I think. Again, Kishore will tell me.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ah, I didn't see that possibility.

    I saw Chas as diminutive of Charles.

    But Sandhya's Chas[e] is also a possibility and I, as a rabid fan of the writer Chase in my college days, congratulate her.

    Could you name some typical characteristics of the writer?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Cartoon under 8d is hilarious - when you have seen the headline on the newspaper page facing you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. CV, 841 & 846 as usual, you are perfectly correct. This post has something which started out as a typographic ligature. Et is the origin of this ligature and is still in use in this computer era. I, however, interpreted this clue in the medical sense of a ligature.

    ReplyDelete
  12. CV 849: Fast, crime stories well written. Usually not too long winding. I first came across the words grand, broad, heist, payroll etc in his books.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 28 - Drag, without power, named useless (4) (p-)(N+)ULL

    As per the instruction in the clue, I get (-p)ULL N. Is that right or am I reading it wrong?

    ReplyDelete
  14. Bhavan

    A very good question!

    You're right! But not completely!

    The setter's intention is that you put N where you removed P (wink, wink).

    ReplyDelete
  15. The intention is plain and nothing else fits the answer, but I was asking about the wordplay.

    Similarly is RENT,DEMAND a phrase in the dictionary? I haven't looked in chambers yet but wondering.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Kishore

    Re: Chase

    Agreed on all counts.

    May endings would be totally unexpected. But not as in the work of some writers (I forget examples) in which they say one thing happened and some paras further down merely add something to suggest that it did not happen.

    However, one device of Chase's that I didn't like was: some novels having a few last paras wherein in a short compass he summarised many happenings.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anyone here remember Chase from House?

    ReplyDelete
  18. CV 906, yes, some endings were Like a Hole in the Head.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Bhavan

    Another good question from you!

    RENT DEMAND will not be in Chambers or any standard dict.

    However, it is not completely made up by the setter. We could hear the phrases used in Indian conversations.

    Just a minute! Let me check.

    See R????????? in CC. Quite British! Dave?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Kishore

    Don't remind me of A Hole in the Head.

    In the recent surgery that I had, I had four made in my head. And they have left visible dents on my cranium.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Several nice things!

    Loved solving this one, so putting down a few things I liked very much.

    1) Use of 'showered' as anagrind in 9A

    2) Cleverness of the CD at 16A

    3) Good surfaces at 2D and 17D, among a few others.

    Grouse: 4D looked like a word from last week's set and use of boy or man for arbitrary English names (such words can only be worked backwards, after arriving at the solution). Also, I'd have expected Gridman to be naughtier with 23D ;)

    ReplyDelete
  22. 4D looked like a word from last week's set

    Sudalamani

    You're right, though it did not occur to me until you pointed it out. What was that setter's clue?

    Anyway, THC setters work together, but they work apart (some Frost line). So they wouldn't know of others' gridfills. It seems TH does not (for obvious reasons) keep track of word frequencies.

    ReplyDelete
  23. CV 916, that was the first title that came back and matched to a T. Hope the shock of white has covered the dents by now. All the best.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Had a tough time with unpronounceable words and unknown meanings

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anyway, THC setters work together, but they work apart

    Diversity in Unity?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Indian papers too have carried the following item

    http://www.torontosun.com/2011/07/26/wisconsin-professor-wins-bad-writing-award

    This reminds me of a column (title I forget) in Bombaythe magazine (from India Today stable) which invited readers to send paras that they found highly convoluted.

    Once they used an item that I sent.

    Who was the writer?

    No less a person than Justice V R Krishna Iyer who, like Caesar's wife, is above suspicion and who you know can NEVER be accused of being non compos mentis and whose modus operandi is quite well known and who often delivers obiter dicta.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Sorry - slept in! I think rent demand is fine, it didn't raise any hackles as I put it in. Quite often the red bills that come through are known as final demands. Loved the word play on letter though.
    Again a lovely, if belated, start to the day!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Cpl of questions:

    1A: Is TT a shortform for Race ?

    6A:
    The way I read it:
    Watering hole == pool
    circle around == loop

    Not sure where the reversal indicator is, hence the query.

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  29. The famous TT motorbike race is held on the Isle of Man every year.

    ReplyDelete
  30. And the way I read the other clue was

    Watering hole -- pool
    Circle -- reversal indicator
    Around -- loop

    ReplyDelete
  31. David

    While I agree that your parsing is the closest to being correct, I can't quite see why Loop=around. Especially, it means equating an adverb with a verb, which I don't find very acceptable.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I guess I was giving it the leniency of sounds like "a round"

    ReplyDelete
  33. Actually the original clue was:

    Circle around watering-hole (4) for LOOP

    Yesterday at the last minute G thought he should change it because it is ambiguous - whether the ans. is LOOP or POOL.

    While revising, G seems to have written a clue for POOL ! (without looking at the sol. grid for the entry at the slot!)

    Sorry! In any case, I can explain it away:

    In the present clue "Watering-hole to circle around" POOL does a turn around so you get LOOP. What then is the rev ind? '[C]ircle around' does double duty! Isn't 'circle around' tautological?
    Maybe.

    As for the surface reading, some word are implicit, thus:

    Watering-hole [for one to] to circle around

    Idhu eppadi irukku?

    ReplyDelete
  34. Appadidhan naanum ninaichen.

    ReplyDelete
  35. G concedes he is "explaining it away", but in any case I don't think double duties are legal devices for setters. How are the solvers to know if an element is working twice? Also, 'a round' also is not a fair thing, as we are interested in 'word'play here as opposed to 'letter'play.

    So, idhu anyayama irukku :P

    ReplyDelete
  36. While G may be 'explaining away' there is nothing wrong with Double devices. They are 'legal' and ok if they make good surface reading

    ReplyDelete
  37. Grouse/gripes:

    24A Is Cress a vegetable? The online references I referred to call it a plant related to mustard.

    29A - This type of DD is not a favourite of mine where the two meanings are closely related.


    Having said that, I must admit I liked 16A.


    Colonel,

    Shouldn't the anno. for 11D be {EX}{CITE}(~site)?

    ReplyDelete
  38. cress - a name for many pungent-leaved cruciferous plants of various genera often used as a culinary garnish and in salads (Chambers)

    vegetable - a plant or part of one for food (Chambers)

    Can't the def 'vegetable' for 'cress' be used?

    ReplyDelete
  39. Thanks David, Chaturvasi for the explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  40. I don't think Cress is a vegetable. Its leaves are used just for seasoning - like we use basil, parsley etc. Maybe it could have been clued as a herb.

    I also feel that 6A is a bit unfair. Had it been an &lit, maybe it'd have worked. Now that it's not an &lit, we have an overlapping of definition and wordplay.

    ReplyDelete
  41. It is admitted that 6a is unfair.
    Circumstances under which the mistake happened have been explained above and also 'Sorry' has been mentioned.
    Facetiously, I was trying to explain it away.
    Clues where some components have double duty are not uncommon, though I don't say they can be used. G generally does not use that device, I think.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Deepak

    A suggestion.

    I am greatly impressed by excellent comments made by members here.

    Some new Commenters are on the scene.

    If we click on Blogger profile we do not always get details as not all care to fill in.

    I am wondering if you could have one more blog/page/link called THCC members where we can give some details such as Year of Birth, education, work, etc. That will be interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Chaturvasi@16:04,
    All vegetables may be plants or parts thereof, but not all plants are vegetables. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  44. CV @ 16:51
    I do not know if anyone will enter their details there as they have not done so in their blogger profile. Shall explore the possibility of having a separate file here itself like where I have given my contact details above and THCC commenters can send me the details which I will enter there. Shall work it out and let everyone know. Suggestions could be given as to what details are required.
    I can think of
    Name
    Age
    Education
    Location
    Profession
    Employed with
    Family details

    ReplyDelete
  45. Deepak
    Please do get reactions from other people here before you start that.
    Anyway,re your list. That's about all. Instead of age, it must be Year of Birth.
    Profession alone would do; 'employed with' isn't needed.
    As I said, please wait for others' reactions.

    ReplyDelete
  46. I have created a page THCC members (see the top) for entering details of THCC members. The only problem is that only I can enter the details there. Those interested can sent their details to my email ID deepakgita@gmail.com and I will add the details to the list above

    ReplyDelete
  47. CV @ 18:18
    I have created the page. I can always delete it if the response is poor

    ReplyDelete
  48. "Ligature' to me is a thread or cord which we often use to tie Blood vessels and other hollow tissue in Surgery. The term "ligature mark " is used in hanging or strangulation.I have never thought of it as a "Binding bandage'. Needless to say, I missed this particular clue in spite of dealing with ligatures day in and out.

    ReplyDelete
  49. LIGATURE [2] - DOUBLE DEFINITION
    1) binding, Something that unites; a bond.
    2) bandage - A cord, wire, or bandage used for tying or binding.

    @ CV, Dr S Jagadish, Director Professor & Head, Department of Surgery at JIPMER, Puducherry is an ardent THC solver, though, as he himself told us on this forum, he sits down with the puzzle in the evening after finishing his day's work of surgeries, OPD, Ward work, academics and research. He has been my mentor and senior at both school and college.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Venkatesh

    Yes, I knew that 'jaggu' is a doctor but you have given additional info on him. Thanks.

    It is gratifying to know of such ardent solvers.

    It is also nice to know that we have solvers from such varying fields as defence services, IT, medicine, accountancy, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  51. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Chaturvasi: 4down: Novel horse race: HOUYHNHNM-- !!! Thanks for introducing this as a new word for my dictionary, in my sdolving career of three decades and more. What ecxactly is this? I've not come across this dark horse in any of the UK papers --The Times, Daily Telgraph, Independent, Guardian etc, which I used to solve in Kenya. Would be delighted to know the history and background, on which no other solver seems to have commented.

    I sometimes feel the crop of Hindu compilers have caught a viral from NJ.!!

    More the merrier, eh?

    Raju Umamaheswar

    ReplyDelete

deepakgita@gmail.com